A can of evaporated milk might be waiting in the cupboard for pumpkin pie. Open a second one for the mashed potatoes. Because some of its water has been removed, evaporated milk gives the mash more dairy body than the same splash of regular milk. Start with less than you think you’ll need and add more after the first few folds.

Check the label before you pour
Evaporated milk is unsweetened. Sweetened condensed milk often sits beside it on the shelf and comes in a similar can, but it contains added sugar. Look for the words “evaporated milk” and shake the can before opening, as directed on the label. Warm a small amount in a saucepan while the potatoes drain. It should be warm enough to add without cooling the potatoes, with no need to boil it.
Give the potatoes a chance to dry
Return the drained potatoes to the warm pot for a minute so surface moisture can steam off. Mash with butter and a hand masher, then fold in the warm milk in small splashes. Stop once the potatoes hold soft ridges when you drag a spoon through them. A mixer or food processor can work the potatoes past that point and leave them gluey, so use a spoon for the last adjustments.
Taste after the butter and milk are in. A pinch of salt or a handful of chopped chives can bring the flavor into focus without adding more liquid. If the potatoes tighten up on the way to the table, loosen them with another splash of warm milk. For another side that can share the table, browse our Thanksgiving decorating ideas.
If you are serving gravy, leave the mash a little firmer in the pot. It will soften on the plate, and you can use the rest of the milk another day.





Leave a Reply